BX23S Capabilities
- Thread starter RTG
- Start date
How many is "a lot"? Is it plausible to rent a machine to do them all in a couple days, then buy a BX without a backhoe? Do you have other tasks for the backhoe?
I haven't had a BX backhoe, but I have had a small mini-ex, which most people will say is more capable than the BX. It can dig stumps, but it's very slow going. I'd do it for a couple, but I'd get pretty tired of it if there were a lot. A bigger machine will do them dramatically faster - instead of carefully working around the stump breaking the roots one by one, then slowly rolling it out, you can just put the bucket on the stump and pull.
If you're looking for a weekend hobby for a few years, then yes. If you just need the job done, I'd seriously consider renting a bigger machine (or hiring a guy with a machine who does it all for you in one go).
I haven't had a BX backhoe, but I have had a small mini-ex, which most people will say is more capable than the BX. It can dig stumps, but it's very slow going. I'd do it for a couple, but I'd get pretty tired of it if there were a lot. A bigger machine will do them dramatically faster - instead of carefully working around the stump breaking the roots one by one, then slowly rolling it out, you can just put the bucket on the stump and pull.
If you're looking for a weekend hobby for a few years, then yes. If you just need the job done, I'd seriously consider renting a bigger machine (or hiring a guy with a machine who does it all for you in one go).
85Hokie
Moderator
Staff member
Lifetime Member
Equipment
BX-25D ,PTB. Under Armor, '90&'92-B7100HST's, '06 BX1850 FEL
It will do ANYTHING you want it to!! However - a mans gotta know his limitations! ( Clint Eastwood)
It will do it a small bite at a time !
I have removed many stumps - depending on tree type it will be fine, make sure you have a sawsall or other root cutting device.
I am of the opinion that it is better to buy once - cry once than to rent several times!
It will do it a small bite at a time !
I have removed many stumps - depending on tree type it will be fine, make sure you have a sawsall or other root cutting device.
I am of the opinion that it is better to buy once - cry once than to rent several times!
edritchey
Well-known member
Lifetime Member
Equipment
2026 Kubota T2290-48 2026 Kubota ZD1211L-3-72, 2025 New Holland CNH WM75
Thanks for the info. I probably have about 50 pines that I'll be cutting down. Most of them are in the 4"-6" diameter, but a few are closer to 10". I just bought a property where a pond was dug years ago and the dirt piled in three places. Over time, the pines grew up in the dirt piles. I want to get the pines out and use the dirt for a little fill and grading in a few low spots. I'm not looking for a quick weekend completion. This will be an ongoing project.
Pines have shallow roots. If you cut them tall 5-6-7' up (leverage), you may be able to pull them out of the ground using the backhoe. maybe a footish off the base of the stump you could dig around too break some roots, maybe a bucket deep, then use the bucket on top and shake the tree to break more deeper roots
North Idaho Wolfman
Moderator
Staff member
Lifetime Member
Equipment
L3450DT-GST, Woods FEL, B7100 HSD, FEL, 60" SB, 743 Bobcat with V2203, and more
Yes it will be 'fine', not fast but it WILL do the job. Have removed 1/2 dozen spruces 18-24" diameter last year. Yes slow, but I wasn't in a hurry. If you need speed, rent a full size excavator for the day. Two tricks, cut tree but leave 2-3 feet of the trunk, makes a great 'lever' to wiggle loose the stump. Also dig 3-6 feet from the trunk, depending on the type of tree, so you can cut the roots. They will make it a LOT easier to dig and wiggle the stump out. If all your trees are the same species, you'll figure out in the first 2-3 how best to attack the rest of them. Also be sure to grease all the Zerks before you start !