Shandong Brother Industries LTD China Poor Customer Service Communication

Espicier

New member

Equipment
Kubota SVL 95
Oct 18, 2023
27
0
1
Melbourne
I have dealt with other Chinese companies and got a good result on rippers, post driver, fixed knot fencing star pickets etc but came undone with this particular company.
 

Ktrim

Well-known member

Equipment
B2400, lA352 loader,3pth quick hitch/z122r zero turn/restored 52 farmall super a
Dec 23, 2020
444
369
63
Nazareth Pa
My only question to all this is.
What happens when the Chinese equipment you're buying;that's not not a known brand; breaks?
How do you get parts?
Or are we talking so cheap that if it breaks, its disposable?
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

Espicier

New member

Equipment
Kubota SVL 95
Oct 18, 2023
27
0
1
Melbourne
Some of the Chinese companies make a higher standard product than others. I always buy the breakable spare parts where I can. I wouldn't buy anything more complex like a forestry mulcher.
 

PaulL

Well-known member

Equipment
B2601
Jul 17, 2017
2,533
1,489
113
NZ
My only question to all this is.
What happens when the Chinese equipment you're buying;that's not not a known brand; breaks?
How do you get parts?
Or are we talking so cheap that if it breaks, its disposable?
I bought a chipper. It's basically a knockoff of a Wallenstein. Probably not parts interchangeable, but most things that might break are bearings or things I can weld. It's a risk. But it was half the price of a branded chipper - things are expensive in my country.
 

mikester

Well-known member

Equipment
M59 TLB
Oct 21, 2017
3,819
2,440
113
Canada
www.divergentstuff.ca
I bought a chipper. It's basically a knockoff of a Wallenstein. Probably not parts interchangeable, but most things that might break are bearings or things I can weld. It's a risk. But it was half the price of a branded chipper - things are expensive in my country.
There's nothing wrong with cheap chinese equipment if you have a machine shop and want a new hobby.

I have a cheap chinesium chipper too. Breaks down or jambs every 15 minutes like clockwork. Everything looks like hand built one-offs.

Endless fun.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

fried1765

Well-known member

Equipment
Kubota L48 TLB, Ford 1920 FEL, Ford 8N, SCAG Liberty Z, Gravely Pro.
Nov 14, 2019
7,966
5,132
113
Eastham, Ma
There's nothing wrong with cheap chinese equipment if you have a machine shop and want a new hobby.

I have a cheap chinesium chipper too. Breaks down or jambs every 15 minutes like clockwork. Everything looks like hand built one-offs.

Endless fun.
Not all Chinesium products are equal.
Knock off products are frequently built one at a time, in small backyard shops.
This is how it often goes throughout Asia.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 user

PJTWIST

New member

Equipment
BOBCAT S70
Oct 20, 2023
16
1
3
China
You will lose your money. I ordered a skidsteer attachment from Shandong Brothers Industries LDT located in china (Hong Kong). they never shipped the product. lost $3250.00. The salesman just kept telling me that my product is on its way. When I ask him for the necessary shipping and port of entry documents, he says he will send them, but then never produces the actual documents. Emailed the management and owner, they did not respond. Contacted the China bank who did the wire transfer with my bank, they would not respond (finally denied my refund claim).
There is a lot of import criminal activity in China and the government does not care and will not get involved.
If you order through Alibaba, you should get "Trade Assurance", but be careful. Before transferring money, to seller; contact Alibaba and be sure the seller submitted Trade Assurance documentation. The seller sent me the Trade Assurance document, so I thought I had it, but the seller never submitted to it Alibaba, therefore Alibaba denied my claim.

Hello Michael,

Surprised to find this thread. I am the guy who contact with you about your order, and you have been sending us meesages today.

Your item was shipped in May 2023.
You canceled the shipment in May, and then finally shipped the item in August.


The roller has been sitting in your China agent's warehouse since May till the second shipment.
I believe the roller has arrived in the US, right?

I can provide bill lading number, or bill lading for anyones reference.
We were surprised that you say the roller was not shipped.


You can call this company to verify about the facticity of this shipment.
- North America shipping agent name is PANDA LOGISTICS (New York), INC.
Contact Person is Christine Kim.
- China shipping agent name is WPLX (World Panda Logistics Co.,Ltd.)


If anyone has interest, I have all the chat logs, past emails with Michael Stolarik.
Also paperwork from WPLX (World Panda Logistics Co.,Ltd.).



The item is shipped, and Michael is not telling the turth.

I can start a new thread if people want to hear the truth.
I have a lot of proof in hand.
 

PJTWIST

New member

Equipment
BOBCAT S70
Oct 20, 2023
16
1
3
China
Hello Michael,

Surprised to find this thread. I am the guy who contact with you about your order, and you have been sending us meesages today.

Your item was shipped in May 2023.
You canceled the shipment in May, and then finally shipped the item in August.


The roller has been sitting in your China agent's warehouse since May till the second shipment.
I believe the roller has arrived in the US, right?

I can provide bill lading number, or bill lading for anyones reference.
We were surprised that you say the roller was not shipped.


You can call this company to verify about the facticity of this shipment.
- North America shipping agent name is PANDA LOGISTICS (New York), INC.
Contact Person is Christine Kim.
- China shipping agent name is WPLX (World Panda Logistics Co.,Ltd.)


If anyone has interest, I have all the chat logs, past emails with Michael Stolarik.
Also paperwork from WPLX (World Panda Logistics Co.,Ltd.).



The item is shipped, and Michael is not telling the turth.

I can start a new thread if people want to hear the truth.
I have a lot of proof in hand.

Michael, if you remember, the roller was customized per your requirement.
As you worry the pivot pin might intefere with the hydraulic quick change on your Kubota.
So we changed the design and made a new roller for you.


You cancelled the shipping in May, with no reasaon, as you changed your mind.
The new roller was already finished and shipped to your China agent's warehouse in Qingdao city.


The roller has been sitting in your agent WPLX's Qingdao, China warehouse since May 2023.
We don't have access to your roller during this time as it is your product now, and only your agent has the access to it.

The roller has left our plant since May 2023. Why would you say it is not shipped?

Your item was finally shipped in later August 2023 by your own agent World Panda Logistics Co.,Ltd.



We can share with anyone who is interested, about the order details.
Including BILL LADING, the roller is now in the US warehouse.


I can start a new thread or make a video, so everyone can have better understanding why we say Michael is lying.


I must say, what Michael said in this thread it not telling the truth.
His express is very emotional, and with a lot bias.

We don't have to fool to make a life. But Michael seems to be doing things this way.

Attached the bill lading as reference.
BL.jpg
 

D2Cat

Well-known member
Lifetime Member

Equipment
L305DT, B7100HST, TG1860, TG1860D, L4240
Mar 27, 2014
14,259
6,442
113
40 miles south of Kansas City
Sounds like Michael needs to get a hold of his agent World Panda Logistics Co.,Ltd. and get the delivery of his item.
 

PJTWIST

New member

Equipment
BOBCAT S70
Oct 20, 2023
16
1
3
China
Sounds like Michael needs to get a hold of his agent World Panda Logistics Co.,Ltd. and get the delivery of his item.
Yes, it is.

Somehow it seems to us that Michael does not undertstand about the shipping.

We agreed as FOB_QINGDAO, not CFR OR CIF.
With FOB, World Panda is only responsible to Michael, and will only follow his orders.

But Michael has been asking us to give his agent instructions.
Which is wrong, as Michael's agent won't follow our orders.

So Panda Logistics stopped the shipping in May when Michael asked them to.
And shipped again in August when Michael told them to do it.
 

Espicier

New member

Equipment
Kubota SVL 95
Oct 18, 2023
27
0
1
Melbourne
The guy D2 Cat and others are responding to is Harvey SU from Shandong Brother Trading International. I have been waiting 5 months for my skid steer attachments from him. I won't say too much today and if I eventually get my items I will publicly state it here. But I will respond to one thing that was said about shipping. They sell the items with a CIF price and when you question why the products are late it suddenly becomes FOB and then they even make FOB difficult to delay further .
Micheal has probably been through a nightmare and this may have only been resolved through this thread.
If it in fact has been resolved? My nightmare continues
 

PJTWIST

New member

Equipment
BOBCAT S70
Oct 20, 2023
16
1
3
China
The guy D2 Cat and others are responding to is Harvey SU from Shandong Brother Trading International. I have been waiting 5 months for my skid steer attachments from him. I won't say too much today and if I eventually get my items I will publicly state it here. But I will respond to one thing that was said about shipping. They sell the items with a CIF price and when you question why the products are late it suddenly becomes FOB and then they even make FOB difficult to delay further .
Micheal has probably been through a nightmare and this may have only been resolved through this thread.
If it in fact has been resolved? My nightmare continues
Hi, thanks for sending me this post by Michael.

First I want to apologize for the delay with the seeder.
Our parts supplier failed to deliver the wheel part for it on time, all the seeder orders in recent time are delayed because of this. We looked for another part supplier and had them made the parts for us.

It is our mistake, and we will apply for extra discounts like parts and send together for free.
We have talked about the same thing in the email. I hope this is OK.

The seeder is not a very popular product, so we don't keep the seeder in stock.

The other products are already finished, but the seeder is delaying the shipment.
You can cancel the seeder if you want to.

This is our mistake, and we really don't have any excuses for this.
 

PJTWIST

New member

Equipment
BOBCAT S70
Oct 20, 2023
16
1
3
China
The guy D2 Cat and others are responding to is Harvey SU from Shandong Brother Trading International. I have been waiting 5 months for my skid steer attachments from him. I won't say too much today and if I eventually get my items I will publicly state it here. But I will respond to one thing that was said about shipping. They sell the items with a CIF price and when you question why the products are late it suddenly becomes FOB and then they even make FOB difficult to delay further .
Micheal has probably been through a nightmare and this may have only been resolved through this thread.
If it in fact has been resolved? My nightmare continues
The main reason I am here sending the post is because you have got very annoyed after seeing Michael's post.
Michael is a very emotional guy and acting very unstable, so I don’t care much about it.

But his words have very strong influence over you.



You sent me Michael's post on Sep 25, 2023, and you have been losing temp since then, saying you are scammed, and you are in a worse situation than Michael does.
It is imperative to make some declaration here, as we don’t want you to feel this bad.

I sent pictures of the finished products, and you say it is not for your order.
I don’t know what to do.

On the very same day, Sep 25, 2023, I made a 9 pages PDF file explaining why Michael is lying.
Pictures and words including how he started the order, how he changed the order design, when we first shipped, when he cancelled the shipping, when he finally shipped it in August.
You did not belive it.

I have also sent the bill lading to you, said you can call Michael or the shipping agent world panda express. The phone number is on the bill lading.

But you did not check with anyone, right?

Even in your last post under this thread, you still think Michael is the victim.
You still don't believe a single word we said, thanks to Michael.



Did you really do anything to check about the truth?
Or do you really care?


For you, this thread is acting like a court.
Do you think so?
 

PJTWIST

New member

Equipment
BOBCAT S70
Oct 20, 2023
16
1
3
China
The guy D2 Cat and others are responding to is Harvey SU from Shandong Brother Trading International. I have been waiting 5 months for my skid steer attachments from him. I won't say too much today and if I eventually get my items I will publicly state it here. But I will respond to one thing that was said about shipping. They sell the items with a CIF price and when you question why the products are late it suddenly becomes FOB and then they even make FOB difficult to delay further .
Micheal has probably been through a nightmare and this may have only been resolved through this thread.
If it in fact has been resolved? My nightmare continues
If you look at the PI, it says FOB_QINGDAO.
How would you say it is CIF?


Since you term is FOB_QINGDAO, you did not pay shipping rates to us either.
We did not fool around on this part, do you agree?

I sent you pictures of the finished products, for some item you said that is old products we made before.
i don't know what to do.


We can also change to CIF, help you with shipping to your country and you can pay us the shipping rates.
It is a very easy thing and we always do this when a customer requests so, including your order.

But this time, we decided not to.

Because we worry even when we shipped, you might say we did not ship your term and start a post here.
Sometimes people just make things up on the internet as there is no consequence for them.

The business is between you and us, but now you have open a court and trying to judge us.
So we must act very carefully.

I hope you understand.
 

PJTWIST

New member

Equipment
BOBCAT S70
Oct 20, 2023
16
1
3
China
The guy D2 Cat and others are responding to is Harvey SU from Shandong Brother Trading International. I have been waiting 5 months for my skid steer attachments from him. I won't say too much today and if I eventually get my items I will publicly state it here. But I will respond to one thing that was said about shipping. They sell the items with a CIF price and when you question why the products are late it suddenly becomes FOB and then they even make FOB difficult to delay further .
Micheal has probably been through a nightmare and this may have only been resolved through this thread.
If it in fact has been resolved? My nightmare continues
If you look at the PI, it says FOB_QINGDAO.
How would you say it is CIF?


Since you term is FOB_QINGDAO, you did not pay shipping rates to us either.
We did not fool around on this part, do you agree?

I sent you pictures of the finished products, for some item you said that is old products we made before.
i don't know what to do.


We can also change to CIF, help you with shipping to your country and you can pay us the shipping rates.
It is a very easy thing and we always do this when a customer requests so, including your order.

But this time, we decided not to.

Because we worry even when we shipped, you might say we did not ship your term and start a post here.
Sometimes people just make things up on the internet as there is no consequence for them.

The business is between you and us, but now you have open a court and trying to judge us.
So we must act very carefully.

I hope you understand.


That is why we come with the proposal and request of having a 3rd party to come and inspect the goods.
Of course, the 3rd party will be assigned by your side, and you might need to pay them.

Inspection happens in international business, customers sometimes come and inspect the products by themsleves, but also ask 3rd party to do so.

Because whatever we say, you always get the conclusion that we are scammers.
We don't feel confortable being called this way, so let us give it to the 3rd party as you can trust them.

I told the workshop to take the products out of the package and wait for inspection.

Process would be:
1.) Product inspected by 3rd party
2.) Report made by 3rd party
3.) You review the report
4.) if all good, we will book the container with your agent, you can pay your agent directly, no need to pay us for shipping
5.) 3rd party need to be here to inspect the whole loading process, so we both know all products are in the container.

In this case, we make sure no one fools around.
This is the best and only solution we can find.

Unless you fly to China and inspect the goods.

But you have been ignoring our request of doing such.

WHY?