I want a root grapple for my MX5100. I was leaning towards EA but, well that is not going to happen. Who else makes a good grapple and what size would be best? I am not afraid to run equipment to its limits so it should have a reputation of being stout, but at the same time I do not want to make too much sacrifice on lifting capacity because its such a beast.
MX5100 Root Grapple?
- Thread starter Cavalry
- Start date
Good day.
Depending on on how many lids wanting…long bottom style, correct? If EA not a consideration(I know lots of comments about EA but I am personally not sure of what going on there…I don’t think any of us are, but maybe not bad idea to look other places if doubt…seems like some smoke there at a minimum), then I would consider MTL or Virnig. LP has a nice one but I did not think it was price competitive to be a contender…maybe check that at your dealer though. Good luck.
I honestly am torn on how many lids. I can see the advantage on either and the disadvantage as well. By long bottom style you mean like roughly a bucket depth tine? I think I would do better with short tines like the homestead ones.Good day.
Depending on on how many lids wanting…long bottom style, correct? If EA not a consideration(I know lots of comments about EA but I am personally not sure of what going on there…I don’t think any of us are, but maybe not bad idea to look other places if doubt…seems like some smoke there at a minimum), then I would consider MTL or Virnig. LP has a nice one but I did not think it was price competitive to be a contender…maybe check that at your dealer though. Good luck.
As far as using any of my local dealers, I would rather buy online and have it shipped to me. I have had enough bad encounters, snoody behavior and shit service.
I have a clam style single lid LP for my B…I understand it’s not apple to apples relative to my Mx, but for non straight logs especially large logs, they can drop out…maybe they are to big for my grapple so could be operator error too.
So for that reason when I purchased for MX I went with long bottom dual lid…I think the separate lids are going to help hold odd shapes better (non straight logs or maybe they have a fork in them or something). If truly raking the ground a lot maybe a clamshell is better…for picking up and hauling back to the barn, I think the long bottom is going to work better for me. I’ve used a friends long bottom dual lid previously and for my use I think it did better so I went with that style for the Mx. YMMV. For that style as mentioned above I think MTL is worth a look…they seemed heavier built than EA and they were responsive by email. It’s worth a couple clicks to check em out IMO. Good luck. 
OntheRidge
Well-known member
Lifetime Member
Equipment
Kubota L47 TLB, Homestead 55" grapple, LP 1684 rear blade, WR Long 84" snowplow
I am a big fan of Homestead. I am running a 55" Pinnacle on my L47. Quality product, and a 10% military discount. Good Luck!
homesteadimplements.com
Grapples - Homestead Implements
Shop Heavy-Duty Hardox 450 Universal Quick-Attach Compatible Grapples from Homestead Implements.
homesteadimplements.com
I ordered the homestead pinnacle 55 two days ago for my mx5100. I looked at a lot of grapples and many are 4-500lbs.
I wanted to save weight to preserve as much lift capacity as I could.
seamless on line process with Homestead. I should be moving logs with it by the end of March. They have a lighter less expensive light duty series that might have been good enough for moving logs and brush.
I was going to get ea 55 but they are not answering the phone or emails.
I wanted to save weight to preserve as much lift capacity as I could.
seamless on line process with Homestead. I should be moving logs with it by the end of March. They have a lighter less expensive light duty series that might have been good enough for moving logs and brush.
I was going to get ea 55 but they are not answering the phone or emails.
Runs With Scissors
Well-known member
Equipment
L2501 TLB , Grappel, Brush Hog, Box Blade, Ballast box, Forks, Tiller, PH digger
If I had to do it over, I would get a dual lid grapple.
Many times I have dropped stuff because one side did not grip well because the other side had a big piece in it.
The one thing I was really surprised at when I started using my grapple was how bad it was at picking up a "scoop" of bucked rounds.....
It basically only does "one at a time" because one side always has a big piece in it preventing the other side from closing...
I have a Homestead Pinnacle series box blade that I have been very happy with, and I appreciated the 10% Veterans discount too.
No problems with delivery and everything was as expected. I have no experience with their grapples though.
Many times I have dropped stuff because one side did not grip well because the other side had a big piece in it.
The one thing I was really surprised at when I started using my grapple was how bad it was at picking up a "scoop" of bucked rounds.....
It basically only does "one at a time" because one side always has a big piece in it preventing the other side from closing...
I have a Homestead Pinnacle series box blade that I have been very happy with, and I appreciated the 10% Veterans discount too.
No problems with delivery and everything was as expected. I have no experience with their grapples though.
BAP
Well-known member
Lifetime Member
Equipment
2012 Kubota 2920, 60MMM, FEL, BH65 48" Bush Hog, 60"Backblade, B2782B Snowblower
Check out Homestead Implements, they are made in Jamestown, NY. Depending upon where in NY you live, they may not be to far from you.
homesteadimplements.com
Homestead Implements - Unearth Your Implement
homesteadimplements.com
I kind of thought I wanted a short bottom, but the MTL look attractive. Its not Hardox, but I can face it if need be down the road.For that style as mentioned above I think MTL is worth a look…they seemed heavier built than EA and they were responsive by email. It’s worth a couple clicks to check em out IMO. Good luck.