I bought a Super Split HD early last winter. Here are my findings.....
If high production is what you're after, the kinetic wins hands down. Basically an auto cycle with 3 second cycle time. If consistent sized finished wood with little waste is what you're after, the kinetic wins again. Here is a pic I just took of the wood shed. Bottom lighter colored wood was split a couple weeks ago with the SS. Darker wood was split last year with a hydo and 4 way wedge.
Sure you can get the same consistent sized wood with a hydro, but it will come with a penalty in production. I can keep 3 people as busy as they can handle with the SS as long as I have wood to feed it.
It will run all day, and then some, on a single tank of gas. Its a 5hp honda engine running at 3000 RPM.
Someone asked about what happens if the rack stalls... There is a centrifugal clutch on the engine that drives the flywheels. If the wood doesn't split on the first try, the clutch disengages. The splitter works basically via gear reduction with the flywheels storing some energy. It doesn't solely rely on the stored energy in the flywheels to do the splitting.
HOWEVER.... there are some downsides specific to a kinetic and a couple specific to the SS.
The first and foremost is it likes straight grained wood. It will cut through crotches and knots, but does have a tendency to twist on the wedge and the push block is small enough that it can lose contact with the wood and eventually wedge itself on the side of a split. This requires a tool of sorts to pound the wood off the wedge. The same thing can happen if you find a piece that it really doesn't want to split... But that's been rare. Some crotches and elm are all Ive found that Ive had to toss aside.
Second, you need to be on your toes. With a 3 second cycle time, things happen fast. You HAVE to pay attention to where your hands, AND face/head are. Leaning over the splitting area while something is being split is a huge no no. There is a good possibility you will at the worst lose some teeth, at the least end up with stitches if a piece decides to shoot up....
Now.... Specific to the SS, or any splitter that uses cam followers instead of bearings. The SS uses cam followers, which is basically a bearing that is designed to have a constant flow of oil through it. There is a hole on the inside that allow oil to enter the bearing. Problem with this on a splitter is eventually the oil dries up and there is no good way to replace the lubricant. Which is what folks are referring to when they mention the follower that rides along the beam freezes up. This is what leads to a groove being ground into the beam. Some folks have fixed this issue by replacing the small follower that ride on the beam with 2 sealed bearings. I tried this but I would have to spread the holder open to accommodate the double bearings. I didn't want to do this so I turned to greasing the bearings. I pulled all the followers, which on my splitter there are 7. I loaded the center hole up with grease and with my thumb and fore finger put the center under pressure. Then by spinning the outer race, the grease was pushed into the bearing. I havent had an issue with a frozen bearing since, and I have better lubircant in the bearing that wont dry out or allow crud into the bearing which is what causes it to seize in the first place.